What Are the Two Types of Medicine Cabinets?

Medicine cabinets are essential fixtures in many bathrooms, offering a blend of functionality and style. They are convenient storage spaces for toiletries, medications, and other personal care items. When you're upgrading or installing a medicine cabinet, it's essential to understand the various options available. The two most common types are surface-mount medicine cabinets and recessed medicine cabinets.

 

In this article, we'll explore the key differences between these two types of medicine cabinets, helping you choose the one that best fits your bathroom's needs. Whether you're renovating or building a new bathroom, understanding the differences in installation, functionality, and aesthetics can significantly impact your overall experience.

 

Surface Mount Medicine Cabinets

 

What is a Surface Mount Medicine Cabinet?

 

A surface-mount medicine cabinet is designed to be installed directly onto the wall's surface rather than being recessed into the wall. This type of cabinet is perfect for bathrooms with limited wall space or where the wall structure doesn't allow for a recessed cabinet. The cabinet's edges and framing will typically be visible with a surface mount cabinet, adding an extra design layer to your bathroom.

 

Key Features of Surface Mount Medicine Cabinets

 

Easy Installation: Surface-mount medicine cabinets don't require any wall excavation, so they are relatively easy to install. This can be a huge advantage for homeowners wanting a quick installation process.

 

More Visible: Unlike recessed cabinets, which are often flush with the wall, surface mount cabinets protrude slightly from the wall, making them more noticeable. This can be a stylish choice if you want to make a statement with your bathroom decor.

 

More Storage Space: Surface mount cabinets typically offer more storage space inside since there is no need to account for the wall's depth. This allows for deeper shelves and a larger storage area.

 

Variety of Styles: These cabinets are available in various materials, colors, and finishes, making it easy to find one that fits your bathroom's aesthetic.

 

Pros of Surface Mount Medicine Cabinets

 

Ideal for Shallow Walls: A surface-mount medicine cabinet is an excellent solution if your bathroom walls are not deep enough for a recessed cabinet. This type of cabinet doesn't require much behind-the-wall space.

 

Flexible Placement: Surface-mount cabinets can be installed at any height that best suits your needs, offering greater flexibility in placement.

 

No Wall Modification Needed: Surface-mount medicine cabinets are perfect for renters or people who don't want to alter the structure of their bathroom. They are also a good option for those with old homes where wall framing may not be suitable for recessed installation.

 

More straightforward to Replace: If you ever want to replace your surface mount medicine cabinet, it is more manageable without worrying about repairing drywall or adjusting the wall structure.

 

Cons of Surface Mount Medicine Cabinets

 

 

 

Protrudes from the Wall: The most significant disadvantage is that the cabinet sticks out from the wall, which can create a visual disruption in a bathroom with limited space. It may also pose a slight obstruction in smaller bathrooms.

 

Less Sleek Aesthetic: Since surface mount cabinets don't blend flush with the wall, they might not offer the sleek, integrated look that many homeowners desire.

 

Potential for Less Spaciousness: Although surface-mount cabinets offer more storage depth than recessed cabinets, they can take up more wall space, which can be a concern in tiny bathrooms.

 

Recessed Medicine Cabinets

 

What is a Recessed Medicine Cabinet?

 

A recessed medicine cabinet is installed directly into the wall, with the cabinet's edges sitting flush with the surrounding wall. These cabinets are designed to be installed between wall studs, requiring more precise measurements and installation. Because they're recessed into the wall, these cabinets don't protrude and can save valuable space in smaller bathrooms.

 

Key Features of Recessed Medicine Cabinets

 

Sleek Design: Recessed medicine cabinets are flush with the wall, giving them a clean, modern, and minimalist look. This style is ideal for contemporary or small bathrooms where you want a sleek, seamless design.

 

Space-saving: Since the cabinet is installed into the wall, it doesn't take up any additional room. This is particularly beneficial in tight spaces where every inch of room matters.

 

Hidden Storage: A recessed cabinet offers a more discreet storage solution. Tucked away, it provides a more streamlined and less cluttered look.

 

Wall Structure Considerations: Recessed cabinets require proper wall framing and structural integrity. They are often installed between studs, which means the wall needs to have the correct spacing and depth to accommodate the cabinet.

 

Pros of Recessed Medicine Cabinets

 

Space-Efficient: Recessed cabinets take up no additional space in your bathroom. Since they are installed inside the wall, they're perfect for smaller bathrooms where space is at a premium.

 

Streamlined Appearance: These cabinets offer a more polished and professional look, particularly in modern bathrooms. The flush design creates a clean, uninterrupted surface.

 

No Protrusion: Recessed cabinets are ideal for people who want their bathrooms to feel open and spacious because they don't protrude into the room.

 

Increased Aesthetic Appeal: A recessed medicine cabinet can look more integrated into the wall, offering a more customized appearance, which is especially important in high-end bathrooms or contemporary designs.

 

Cons of Recessed Medicine Cabinets

 

Complex Installation: Installing a recessed medicine cabinet is more involved. It may require cutting into drywall, repositioning studs, or ensuring the wall can accommodate the depth of the cabinet. This is often a job for professionals.

 

Less Storage Depth: Since the cabinet is installed within the wall, it may offer less internal storage depth compared to surface-mount cabinets. This could be a drawback if you need a deeper cabinet for larger bottles or bulky items.

 

Permanent Installation: Once a recessed cabinet is installed, replacing or adjusting it can be difficult without extensive renovation work. It's also not as easy to remove as a surface-mount cabinet.

Key Differences Between Surface Mount and Recessed Medicine Cabinets

1. Installation Process

· Surface Mount Medicine Cabinets: Easier to install, especially for DIY enthusiasts. They simply need to be mounted on the wall.

· Recessed Medicine Cabinets: Require more work and expertise, as they need to be installed between studs and may involve modifying the wall.

2. Aesthetic

· Surface Mount Medicine Cabinets: Often have a more noticeable design since they protrude from the wall. This can work well in traditional or more decorative bathroom designs.

· Recessed Medicine Cabinets: Offer a cleaner, more modern look because they sit flush with the wall. They work best in minimalistic or modern spaces.

3. Space Requirements

· Surface Mount Medicine Cabinets: Can be used in any bathroom, even with shallow walls. However, they take up more room on the wall since they protrude.

· Recessed Medicine Cabinets: Ideal for bathrooms where space is tight. These cabinets don’t take up any extra space but require enough depth within the wall for installation.

4. Storage Capacity

· Surface Mount Medicine Cabinets: Generally offer more internal depth and storage space, especially for larger or bulkier items.

· Recessed Medicine Cabinets: May have less storage depth due to the need to fit within the wall's space.

Which Type of Medicine Cabinet Is Right for You?

When choosing between a surface mount medicine cabinet and a recessed medicine cabinet, it’s essential to consider the size of your bathroom, your design preferences, and your storage needs.

· Go with a surface mount medicine cabinet if:

o You have a shallow or non-recessed wall structure.

o You want a cabinet with deeper storage space.

o You are looking for an easy-to-install, versatile solution.

· Go with a recessed medicine cabinet if:

o You have a small bathroom and need to save space.

o You prefer a sleek, minimalist design.

o You’re ready for a more permanent installation and are looking for a modern aesthetic.

Both options have their unique advantages, and the best choice depends on your specific bathroom needs and personal preferences.

Takeaway

Choosing the right medicine cabinet is an important decision for your bathroom’s functionality and style. Whether you opt for a surface mount medicine cabinet for ease of installation and extra storage or a recessed medicine cabinet for a sleek, space-saving design, understanding the pros and cons of each type will help you make an informed decision. Take the time to assess your needs, bathroom space, and design goals, and you’ll be well on your way to selecting the perfect cabinet for your home.

With the right medicine cabinet in place, your bathroom will feel more organized, functional, and visually appealing. Happy renovating!